Emma’s Random (Reylo) Thoughts Part 6: Balancing Off Balance


I really didn’t think I was going to write about this topic again, but a few things happened.

1 The teaser trailer came out about a month ago.


2 The Last Jedi poster was also released to the public.

Star Wars: Episode VIII - The Last Jedi

3 I noticed that, while I don’t get a lot of views, people are viewing the Reylo posts.  So, give the people what they want…

In this installment of Reylo thoughts, we discuss balance and unity in two famous philosophical and religious ideas and how Reylo both alludes to them and also subverts them.   You know, mindless entertainment.

The Last Jedi Trailer, when I first saw it, shocked me because it addresses an idea that Reylo supporters have discussed in detail before; the idea of balance in the Force.

For example.

A huge theme in Star Wars, and one which the filmmakers have said they are going to focus on in this new trilogy, is the need to balance the Force and the co-dependent yin/yang nature of its light and dark sides. A lot of people think the light side equals good and the dark side equals bad. But, while that has been the case in the specific characters we’ve usually met in the films, it’s actually far more complicated. In fact, instead of each side being purely good or evil,  good comes from the balance of both sides, and evil comes from leaning more toward one side than the other.


Star Wars Connection also touched on that idea as well.

Both of these analyses touch on the idea of yin and yang.

Yin and yang argues that opposite forces (light and dark, heat and cold) are not so much opposing as they are complementary and interdependent.  Yin and yang sees masculinity and femininity through this lens.  These states are not so much opposing or antagonistic; but rather they depend upon one another and complement one another.  Neither yin nor yang should dominate according to this understanding of the universe; rather they should work together and balance one another.

A person who commented on the Reylo posts said that Reylo would make Rey common.  While I disagree that a Virgin Rey would be groundbreaking in any way, I do think that Reylo would render Rey ‘common’, in a way.  However, here’s the kicker.  It also makes Kylo Ren common.

In yin and yang analysis, Kylo Ren and Rey represent the two sides of the Force, the dark side and the light.  The light side cannot defeat the dark, or vice versa.  The two sides must balance.  In this sense, any partnership between Kylo Ren and Rey, sexual or otherwise, is not about the two of them as individuals.  Rather, their partnership would serve as a representation of balance of the Force, and a vehicle for that balance.


In a way, it is similar to the traditional Christian understanding of marriage, in which the groom stands for Christ and the bride stands for the Church.  In a way, this is why the old Anglican marriage pronouncement declares “Dearly beloved, we are gathered here in the sight of God, and in the face of this congregation, to join this man and this woman in holy matrimony.”  The speech does not say “John” and “Jane”, in part because the bride and groom stand in for all men and women, for Adam and Eve, and Christ and the Church.

This is all very standard, but in a way, Reylo turns this symbolism on its head.

In Star Wars, Rey is associated with the Light side of the Force, and Kylo Ren is associated with the Dark side of the Force.  This is the opposite of Yin and Yang.  According to Chinese philosophy, femininity is associated with yin, which is associated with darkness and the moon. Masculinity is associated with yang, which is associated with light and the sun.  By associating Rey with the light and Kylo Ren with darkness, Star Wars draws on Yin and Yang and also flips it on its head.

It does the same thing for Christ and the Church imagery.  In Christianity, humanity falls into sin and Christ rescues the Church and two two will be united in heaven.  However, Kylo Ren cannot stand for Christ, because he has fallen to the Dark side and needs redemption.  Some Reylo supporters believe that Rey will bring Kylo Ren back from the Dark side of the Force, which would make her the Christ figure in the story.

Now, will Disney actually go down this path?

I suppose it’s possible.  The trailer does hint strongly at the need for balance between the two sides of the Force.  Even Luke’s line at the end, “It’s time for the Jedi to end,” could signify the rise of Grey Jedi, Jedi who will use both the Light side and Dark side of the Force.

However, it is also not clear that Rey symbolizes the Light Side of the Force, in either the trailer or the poster.

In the trailer, we seem to see an image of Leia when we hear Rey’s voice over narration say, “Light,” implying that Leia signifies the Light side of the Force, not Rey.

This is even clearer in the movie poster.

In the movie poster, half of Luke and Kylo Ren’s faces are shown, bifurcated by the light saber.  In a sense, they represent the two sides of the person, a man split down the middle.   It would be tempting to say that Luke represents the Light Side of the Force.  But I am not so sure.  The image of Luke’s face is stern, large, and menacing.  Surprisingly, he looks more threatening than Kylo Ren.  Also, both he and Kylo Ren are bathed in red light, which has always signified the Dark Side of the Force.  The only blue stems from Rey’s light saber, which is shaped like Kylo Ren’s, and even that is still largely red. Kylo Ren is shown unmasked, angry, but not the frightening monster in the first film.  The poster is ambiguous about who is good and and who is evil in this trio, and suggests perhaps that Luke may not be as good as we believe.

(I would be fine with Luke turning evil, though I don’t think that the majority of Star Wars fans would agree.  If the death of Han Solo was painful for Star Wars fans, then the loss of Luke to the Dark side would be even greater.  That’s why I am fine with it.  Take chances, make mistakes, and get messy Disney!)

What I do think is likely based on the poster, is a blurring of good and evil, darkness and light.  I think that we will see shadows in Luke and Rey, and possibly some light in Kylo Ren.  That would absolutely be for the best.  I think that the poster, and the trailer suggests, that the The Last Jedi’s portrayal of Luke will throw everyone off balance.

I also don’t expect (or want) to see a romantic dynamic between Rey and Kylo Ren in this film.  Sexual dynamic?  Sure, why not?  But romance would be implausible and would not stem from the characters at this point.  For the 9th film?  Too early to say.

One last thought.

I will say it again, can we please get Rey a female friend?







This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Emma’s Random (Reylo) Thoughts Part 6: Balancing Off Balance

  1. Balance! Balance! Balance! Oops, sorry…Okay, so I will not be able to handle it if Luke is Dark. I will seriously lose my mind. Therefore, I really hope Disney doesn’t go that direction. But, a Jedi recognizing that they’ve gotten it wrong? The eschewing of bonds and ties, I mean. That, I can get behind. And let’s be honest, obviously, the Jedi have been doing something wrong because they aren’t getting the necessary balance. And I adored Han Solo, but I quite believe that Kylo Ren can come back, even from patricide. Wow. I’m not saying this well. Okay – at it’s heart, Star Wars is a fairy tale. It is. And fairy tales have formulas. I think that Rey (who already has quite a bit of Dark in her) will come to accept that side of her, and Ren will accept the side of him that pulls to the light. Do I think it will result in a romantic relationship? I think I hope so. I also think that’s a risk because an awful lot of fans out there are still (rightly) angry that Ren killed Han Solo. They may never forgive him, and letting him get the girl wouldn’t be the message those fans like.

  2. And yes…a female friend would be outstanding.

  3. I also had another thought – in Rey’s Force vision, Kylo Ren appears to kill someone who is threatening her, likely a Knight of Ren. This could be part of his long-term redemption process. Also, according to the book, Rey has nightmares and dreams in which a voice tells her to “Wait here; I’ll come back for you sweetheart, I promise.” One of the story checkers (Pablo Hidalgo, maybe) for Star Wars told fans that the voice was a masculine, so it wasn’t her mom. And when he emerges from his shuttle on Takodona, she says that she knows him from a dream, a nightmare. These two are (likely) Force bonded. Plus, Rian Johnson tweeted out pictures of red threads. I just get the feeling evidence is mounting for Reylo. Okay – I’m going to stop bothering you.

  4. Pingback: Killing Sacred Cows: The Last Jedi’s Portrayal of Luke Skywalker | emmasrandomthoughts

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s